EN PL
 

Submitting a review – step by step

 
  1. Sign in as a reviewer or create an account at https://www.editorialsystem.com/zeren.




  2. Having accepted the invitation to review a paper, you can download the full paper by clicking on “Pending reviews” and then “View manuscript (PDF)”.
    However, if you have guessed the identity of the author and there is a conflict of interest, please decline the review invitation.



  3. Then fill out the review form by clicking on “Prepare review”.



    4. The rating scale on the form is from 1 (very poor) to 5 (very good). In the form, you are asked to indicate the following information:
    • the overall value of the article
    • consistency of the title with the paper
    • introduction
    • case description
    • materials and methods
    • results
    • discussion
    • conclusions
    • graphics
    • literature
    • abstract
    • confidential editorial comments (invisible to authors)
    • information for authors


    The reviewer can upload the corrected article (DOCX, PDF, or ODT). In the review form, the reviewer can choose one of four decisions:
    • accept without any changes,
    • accept upon minor changes suggested by the reviewers,
    • accept upon major changes and re-review,
    • reject.
    The selected decision is only a suggestion, since the final decision on a particular paper is always made by the Editorial Team.
  4. The editors are notified of submission of the review by e-mail.
 
Newsletter
 
 
Sign up
Unsubscribe
Most read
Indexes
 
Keywords index
Topics index
Authors index
Journals System - logo
Subsidized by the state budget under the program "Development of scientific journals." Project no. RCN/SP/0118/2021/1. Funding: PLN 64 000. Total value: PLN 64 000. The subject of the program is to support the scientific journal "Zagadnienia Ekonomiki Rolnej / Problems of Agricultural Economics" in the implementation of its development strategy, which includes activities aimed at raising the level of publishing and editorial practices, increasing the impact of the journal on the development of science and the maintenance of the journal in international scientific circulation.
© 2006-2024 Journal hosting platform by Bentus
Scroll to top